I would say that if the birds body is sharp then the movement in the wings is irrelevant I know others would say that high shutter High shutter etc is the must but seriously What do you really think?
My rules for me are:
1. If I like it its good!!
2. If some else likes it, Great!!
3. If they buy it BINGO!!
4. If you don't like it, no one else will because your heart isn't in it....
Allan, I like the movement and the reflection but I'm not so keen on the framing. I guess you have cropped this already but maybe losing a little from the top might help. What do you think?
I like it Allan. The framing itself doesn't bother me, although the brightness in the top area of the frame is a little distracting. I love the wings in motion, though. Its a bit like a gigantical humming bird!