Critique Welcomed Perplexed

[Bob Jarman]

Curious about your preference, if any, toward the sets of images. Elsewhere the less harsh versions have broader appeal, yet I find the harder renditions also appealing to me. Now as the photographer I understand it is 'my vision' but still I am torn between the two.

Especially interested since many of you shoot film and I'd think the second set is more film-like, but maybe a bad supposition on my part.






--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------





Thanks,

Bob

 

[Pete Askew]

Fabulous stuff again, Bob. I prefer the warmer tone and darker rendering of the first two but I like them all very much.

 

[Ivar Dahl-Larsen]

I like unlike Pete the last sequence as the contrast is a bit harder and makes it look as I envision a cemetery.