Darren you are particularly good at this type of photography and in this light. Both good the second draws me more for the composition. Like the tree and the frame work in the water.
cheers guys getting giddy now here, i wasn't sure if the 2nd one was any good, i read an article in a magazine about shooting through thing so i gave it a try, really glad you guys like it
@Julian de'Courcy thank you so much for your kinds words (dusk & after dark is my favourite time for photography)