STANDING

The look that says ............ It's time I put my camera away and scarpered.

Second one is my favourite as well Julian. Good capture.
 
Rather like the eye contact in the second thought the informal in the first is appealing too.But the lighting and the darker tones in the second is the scoring note fro me Julian.......like Mr KFC up there too is in the second as he appears twice in full great catch...:)
 
I'm liking #1 - her distant stare with the Colonel looking on in voyeuristic fashion

#2 has that extra pole on the right which rather closes off the view
 
I like the first in that I find it more comfortable to look at. The second makes me feel a little uncomfortable due to the stare. However, this uncomfortable element does make the photo more interesting than the first in some ways.
 
I like the first in that I find it more comfortable to look at. The second makes me feel a little uncomfortable due to the stare. However, this uncomfortable element does make the photo more interesting than the first in some ways.
Thanks people nice feedback and things I didn't see. Paul you are spot on and I very much had feelings about being uncomfortable. Not sure if it was for the same reason, mine where about displaying an image without consent of a person I don't know. It was at a tram stop and I did walk past . On reflection I wish I had asked if it was ok. After posting I was confused about whether or not it was ok, to post the picture, The confusion being that I did not know. So the conclusion was to post and see how I did feel to find out more about I guess street photography. I wonder if street photographers ever do not show images that for some reason hit a note of invasion that aught not to be crossed? . To me she is a beautiful woman with a great relaxed pose, at the time I felt comfortable ish but a wee bit on edge as anyone not a street photographer who does it occasionally sometimes feels. Thanks for the feedback.
 
I do like them both with, as an image, the second one winning out. There is that element of discomfort about it and the questions raised are interesting. The juxtaposition of 'Colonel Sanders' and the young lady works well, especially in the second. As Chris notes, the staring into the distance in the first adds a different element. The fact that there are no other people visible in the shots creates a certain atmosphere.

I can well understand your dilemma with the images. I guess for me, the question I always ask is, "Why was the image taken?". What was it's purpose? It is a superb image, but is that reason enough? None of this is meant as criticism, as I'm sure you realise, just part of what I run through in my head either when looking around me or when I'm reviewing images. In this case, the contrast between the smiling 'Colonel' and her rather weary and slightly forlorn expression says something - I'm not sure what though. Interesting stuff and it raises many questions both as an image, a genre and about how and why we make images.
 
I do like them both with, as an image, the second one winning out. There is that element of discomfort about it and the questions raised are interesting. The juxtaposition of 'Colonel Sanders' and the young lady works well, especially in the second. As Chris notes, the staring into the distance in the first adds a different element. The fact that there are no other people visible in the shots creates a certain atmosphere.

I can well understand your dilemma with the images. I guess for me, the question I always ask is, "Why was the image taken?". What was it's purpose? It is a superb image, but is that reason enough? None of this is meant as criticism, as I'm sure you realise, just part of what I run through in my head either when looking around me or when I'm reviewing images. In this case, the contrast between the smiling 'Colonel' and her rather weary and slightly forlorn expression says something - I'm not sure what though. Interesting stuff and it raises many questions both as an image, a genre and about how and why we make images.

All good points thanks Pete. I often feel uncomfortable about the use of such images. It was why a while ago a student asked to take my picture and I felt obliged to respond positively even though I dislike my image being taken. Thanks for the comments.
 
Back
Top