Critique Welcomed The grass is always greener ...

[Mike Webb]

Which if any works best?

#1



#2




#3



Although I think I plan a panel of three shots on one board.

Mike

 

[Dan Cattermole]

The first one for me. Very well frames I think.
Is that the back end of Blessed Edwards?

 

[Hamish Gill]

I'd agree, the crop works

 

[Mike Webb]

I'm not sure where Blessed Edwards is but this is in Stourbridge.

 

[Dan Cattermole]

Ha! No where near then. Lol

 

[Julian de'Courcy]

Can I be awkward and say the last image cropped like the first. Too many people in the first and second

 

[Mike Webb]

You mean get the tractor thing off centre where the old boy (who is almost certainly younger than me) is missing?

 

[Brian Moore]

Its #2 for me, Mike. Although all three are likable, #2 seems to have slightly better balance to my eye. (By the way, perhaps you left a slight essence of the man in the 3rd one?)

 

[Mike Webb]

I just noticed that vague smudge as well - dang!

One of these will be a club competition entry next year. But which one?

 

[Pete Askew]

I'm with Brian. The second one works best for me Mike. I find the dark area at the top draws my eye in the first whereas in the second I am lead to the mower and then the man.