Critique Welcomed Isle of Kerrera, Inner Hebrides, Scotland

[Rense Haveman]

The year before yesteryear....

I'd like to have your choice: which one is the best one to hang, and why?


Isle of Kerrera, Inner Hebrides, Scotland by Rense Haveman, on Flickr





Isle of Kerrera, Inner Hebrides, Scotland by Rense Haveman, on Flickr





Isle of Kerrera, Inner Hebrides, Scotland by Rense Haveman, on Flickr

 

[John Holland]

I'd hang all three, but forced to choose I would select the first one. I like the contrast and the sheep add a bit of interest. In the other two, the ruin is right on the third point, where in the first it is not. But that does not seem to bother me, not change my selection.

Regardless of the selection, you can't lose. Well done Rense!

 

[Rense Haveman]

Thank you, John, much appreciated!

They all seem a bit harsh, on my monitor, as if over-sharpened. Or maybe too much clarity added in LR...

I'd hang all three, but forced to choose I would select the first one. I like the contrast and the sheep add a bit of interest. In the other two, the ruin is right on the third point, where in the first it is not. But that does not seem to bother me, not change my selection.

Regardless of the selection, you can't lose. Well done Rense!

 

[Beth Carter]

i really like the third one, though you can't go wrong with any of them.

 

[Pete Askew]

The first has the most immediate appeal I think as I really like the tones and the way the framing makes you focus on the structure and details. However, I suspect that the last would have the most impact on the wall as the composition is so strong on it.

 

[Raza Shaikh]

The year before yesteryear....

I'd like to have your choice: which one is the best one to hang, and why?


Isle of Kerrera, Inner Hebrides, Scotland by Rense Haveman, on Flickr





Isle of Kerrera, Inner Hebrides, Scotland by Rense Haveman, on Flickr





Isle of Kerrera, Inner Hebrides, Scotland by Rense Haveman, on Flickr

Beautiful scenario! I loved to see nature's creativity. Thanks for sharing,

 

[Milan Vjestica]

Excellent set Rense. I think John suned it up well.